Thanks for visiting Carter Bakes! Check out my current flavors. Each cake is baked fresh and created especially for you. All cakes are frosted with handmade Swiss Meringue Buttercream. Elements such as fondant, gum paste, American buttercream, etc. may be used for decoration purposes to achieve the requested look for your design. All custom cakes start at $100 minimum. The final cost will be based on the techniques and elements used in your requested design. 

When you’re ready to inquire about an order, submit your order request here.


  • Cookies

  • Specialty treats (Covered Rice Krispie Treats, Marshmallows, Pretzels, Oreos, etc.) *Limited based on availability 

CUPCAKE and CAKE POP/BALL FLAVORS - $40/dozen (2 dozen minimum*)

  • White Vanilla (can be tinted/colored)

  • Birthday (White Vanilla cake with sprinkles)

  • Mocha (Chocolate cake with coffee)

  • Chocolate Chip (White Vanilla cake with chocolate chips)

  • Red Velvet 

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon


  • Vanilla

  • Mocha

  • White Chocolate 

  • Cream Cheese 

  • Peanut Butter

  • Caramel​

  • Lemon

  • Strawberry

FILLING FLAVORS - Available at additional cost

  • Chocolate Ganache

  • Cream Cheese

  • Oreo Cookies & Cream

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon


COOKIE FLAVORS - $30/dozen 

Mini cookies (Not available for premium cookies) - $30/ 2 dozen (2 dozen minimum)

  • Butter 

  • Traditional Chocolate Chip

  • Milk Chocolate Toffee (milk chocolate toffee pieces with chocolate chips)

  • M&M'S (M&M'S pieces with chocolate chips)

  • Peanut Butter Delight (peanut butter chips, chocolate chips, and embellished with Reese's Pieces candies)

  • Oatmeal (available with and without raisins)​


PREMIUM COOKIES - $40/dozen 

  • Turtle Pecan (caramel bits, pecan pieces, and chocolate)

  • White Chocolate Macadamia (white chocolate chips with macadamia nuts)

CUSTOM COOKIES - Starting at $4/each (1 dozen minimum*)

Sugar cookies decorated with our handmade Swiss Meringue Buttercream and/or royal icing

*Minimum required for treat orders unless accompanied with cake order